According to Morningstar Associate Investment Specialist Joseph Taylor, at first blush there’s not a lot of symmetry for the casual observer to discover when considering Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway and the ASX-listed “diversified investment house” we’ve come to know and frequent: Soul Patts.
But therein lies the adventure.
Both Washington H Soul Pattinson (ASX:SOL) and Berkshire (not Buffett) can trace their history back to the 1800s.
Both businesses own public and private companies with a staunchly long-term mindset.
And most excitingly, both companies have a storied history and a pretty solid track record of beating the market.
Chemistry
SOL started off life as a pharmacy chain about 138 years ago.
They listed on the ASX in 1903, back when it was probably the ASX 7.
After the war they had about 40 shops and then there were 300+.
Then – sometime during the 1970s and 80s when everyone else wasting time rolling stones or thwarting wars – the retail chain became a building materials, telco and resources investor of some note and scale.
These days it’s an ASX50 regular with a market value of over $11 billion.
Today, Soul Patts calls itself “a diversified investment house that is unique in Australia (which aims to grow shareholder wealth through a diversified range of investments that perform throughout market cycles).”
And it kinda does just that.
Here’s the investor presso blurb from March:
• Our capital is opportunity-led
• Our portfolio is flexible as to asset allocation
• Our portfolio is asset backed with no redemption risk
• Our investment horizons are undefined
• Our internalised management results in cost efficiency
Incredibly, all these years later Soul Patts’ net asset value (NAV) stems from those original long-term holdings in three ASX shares:
Brickworks (ASX:BKW) – TPG Telecom (ASX:TPM) – New Hope Corp (ASX:NHC)
Together, Jason says these investments account for around 60% of Soul Patts’ total assets.
Via WSP
“This figure was more like 80% until their takeover of listed investment company Milton in 2021 brought with it with a large portfolio of equities.
“A decent chunk of this portfolio appears to have been sold and freed up for investment in private assets,” he notes.
“Despite the uptick in diversification and a growing private portfolio, sentiment towards Soul Patts continues to be dominated by the fate of Brickworks, TPG and New Hope.”
Brickworks (ASX:BKW)
Soul Patts has a 43% interest in Brickworks, which comprised around 17% of Soul Patts’ NAV as of 31 January.
“Brickworks, in turn, owns 26% of Soul Patts in a cross-shareholding initiated in 1969 to protect both firms from hostile takeovers. This predated the current Corporation Act and would not be permitted today. Our analysts are not aware of a similar ownership structure in the ASX 200, and it could help Soul Patts take a longer term view.
“Brickworks is a conglomerate consisting of building product manufacturing operations, property management and its 26% shareholding in Soul Patts.”
Morningstar Brickworks analyst Esther Holloway estimates that about half of the firm’s enterprise value comes from its holding in Soul Patts, 40% from its property segment and less than 10% from its Australian and North American building products businesses.
In conjunction with 50:50 joint venture partner, Goodman Group, Brickworks’ property business is focused on warehouse property development in Western Sydney. This large residential and industrial area has warehouse development potential due to its proximity to Sydney’s major highways and the soon-to-be-completed Badgerys Creek international airport.
With an undersupply of warehouses in the area, and Goodman’s established relationships with national and international companies, our analysts are bullish about this opportunity. Its current development in Western Sydney’s Eastern Creek has high quality tenants such as Amazon, Coles, and Woolworths.
“Brickworks’ building products segment is trying to reinforce its position as the lowest-cost brick manufacturer in its two segments of Australia and North America. Brickworks entered the United States in 2018 via the acquisition of Glen-Gery, a building product company similar to Brickworks.
“In both geographies, Brickworks follows a strategy of plant rationalization and plant upgrades to improve efficiency, capacity, and sustainability. Product innovation such as a high-end range in bricks, cladding and pavers aids higher gross margins. As a cyclical business, our analysts like Brickworks’ strategy to continuously improve unit costs.
“Our analysts do not think Brickworks has a moat. The industrial property sector lacks significant barriers to entry. Meanwhile, Brickworks’ building materials business doesn’t appear to have any scale-based cost advantages, the most common moat source in commodity businesses.”
Morningstar’s fair value estimate for Brickworks is currently $31 per share.
“This comprises discounted cash flow valuations for the firm’s property rental income and building materials segment, and equity valuations for the Soul Patts stake and property joint venture.
“At a current price of around $26 per share, Brickworks looks undervalued,” Joseph says.
New Hope Corp (ASX:NHC)
“Soul Patts own around 39% of New Hope, having first bought a 50% stake in New Hope Collieries in the 1970s when it was still a private company. As of 31 January, Soul Patts’ stake in New Hope comprised around 16% of its net asset value.
“New Hope offers exposure to global energy demand via increasing thermal coal production at a time when many other miners are winding down or selling their thermal coal assets. The strategy relies on demand for high quality thermal coal remaining robust longer-term. The purchase of a further 40% interest in the Bengalla coal mine in New South Wales in 2018 took its ownership of Bengalla to 80% after the company purchased its initial 40% stake in 2016. Along with the development of New Acland Stage 3, this sees New Hope reliant on thermal coal.
“Our mining analyst Jon Mills recently raised his fair value estimate for New Hope to $5.90 per share, driven by higher thermal coal prices and a weaker Australian dollar. He does, however, allocate a Very High Morningstar Uncertainty Rating to New Hope. Although New Hope has a strong balance sheet and its mines are in or around the lowest quartile of the thermal coal cost curve, much of New Hope’s fair value is driven by near-term earnings, which are dependent on volatile coal prices. He also sees the potential for lower thermal coal use due to environmental concerns as a longer-term risk.
“Due to this Very High uncertainty rating, New Hope shares only have a 3-star Morningstar rating despite currently trading around 15% below Jon’s fair value estimate.”
TPG Telecom (ASX:TPM)
Jospeh says TPG Telecom’s merger with Vodafone in 2020 saw it join Telstra and Optus as Australia’s third heavyweight telco.
“Soul Patts have a 13% equity interest in TPG Telecom, a position arising from its purchase of NBN Television in the 1980s. As of January 31, this investment comprised around 11% of Soul Patts’ net asset value.”
Morningstar media analyst Brian Han reckons the TPG stocks price screens “cheaper than any other company” under Morningstar’s teleco coverage across Australia and New Zealand.
Although the rollout of Australia’s National Broadband Network (NBN) poses a “real threat: to profitability in TPG’s consumer broadband segment, Brian says TPG earnings can recover over the medium term thanks to “a more rational mobile market” and growth in its fixed wireless and corporate segments.
Morningstar analysts have assigned TPG a narrow moat due to the scale of its fibre infrastructure and existing customer base in Australia.
“This means that TPG can spread the costs of technology upgrades, advertising and content rights bidding over a large customer base, which reduces per-subscriber costs and puts TPG in a superior position against many competitors.
“The capital costs required for a new entrant to replicate even a small part of TPG’s infrastructure, scale, and brand power would be prohibitive, especially in a relatively small country such as Australia and a relatively mature industry with low single digit annual growth,” Joseph says.
TPG shares have been weighed down by slower earnings growth as it invests heavily in rolling out 5G, which Brian Han says you can see in the share price, especially given TPG’s longer-term tailwinds from 5G adoption and an increased focus on mobile.
Via Morningstar
At a price of $4.57 on May 27th, TPG shares were around 30% below Morningstar’s fair value estimate of $6.60.
Is Soul Patts undervalued?
Soul Patts’ three biggest investments seem rather cheap, says Joseph.
“But as I alluded to before, they make up a smaller portion of net assets than was once the case.
“As of 31 January, Soul Patts had around $650 million in other strategic long-term holdings, a $2.4 billion portfolio of large-caps and a total of around $3.2 billion across private equity, “emerging companies” and credit investments.
“The company’s biggest private holdings include electrical engineering company Ampcontrol, several farms under Soul Patts Agriculture, Ironbark Asset Management and Aquatic Achievers, which appears to be rolling up swimming schools across Australia.
Soul Patts is also under Morningstar analyst Esther Holloway, who assigns it a fair value of $33 per share – of which 20% stems from its investment in New Hope, 17% from its holding in Brickworks and 15% from its investment in TPG Telecom.
“The balance comes from its other investment holdings. At a current market price of around $32, Soul Patts shares look fairly valued,” Joseph reckons.
The views, information, or opinions expressed in the interviews in this article are solely those of the interviewees and do not represent the views of Stockhead. Stockhead does not provide, endorse or otherwise assume responsibility for any financial product advice contained in this article.
The post MoneyTalks: The 3 ASX stocks which Soul Patts can’t live without appeared first on Stockhead.
